Where Does Guidance Come From? Part 1: Where Do Thoughts Come From?
The question about where Guidance comes from rests on the more basic question of where thoughts come from.
During an evening presentation at a ten day meditation retreat one leader gave a Buddhist talk on perception and mind, aiming to get participants to open their experience. Exploring the sources of mind and perception made a potentially useful Zen experience. I’m sure discovering the foundationless ‘origins’ of the same helped open some people’s minds. I found this talk rather dull.
The next evening another leader opened everyone’s hearts with music and story and then asked: ”Are you sure the thoughts in your mind are really yours? And if they are not, whose are they and where do they come from or source from?” He asked for comments from the group.
I sat there for a while with my tongue between my teeth listening, because I’ve spoken out before in places where my thoughts were not welcome. Then I let go of that old baggage and listened so I could better calibrate my participation.
Group comments were pretty much:
“You cannot really tell. You cannot know for sure what’s your mind and what’s another mind.” I expected more from the level of development of many of the people in that room.
I said, “Thoughts also come from the Spirit of Guidance, and your teachers, and the people that you’re closely linked to. All of their thoughts come in. They all have different tones and energies and signatures so you can often recognize their sources.
“In addition to that, different parts of ourselves, with their different genders, ages, and personality–parts that we may be in touch or out of touch with–all have their own different tones and voices and expressions, which become recognizable as self-knowledge increases.”
I felt a little bit overextended. Then the leader thanked me and commented on the wisdom in the room, and my teacher beamed at me with sweet, appreciative love, conveying a strong sense of support, so I knew I was on track.
At one juncture in my life I was taking direct instruction from a different spiritual teacher who used to assign practices and then go away for a few hours while I did them. He would come back and take me to task for things I was thinking an hour or two into the practice. I was on silence (not talking) for about a month during this time. He met with me every few days and systematically answered for me all of the questions that had arisen for me in the meantime.
Frankly I found it unsettling to realize that we do not technically have any privacy of mind. Upasni Maharaj, a spiritual master from India, used to call the mind, “a public well.”
Of course, in any situation other than direct spiritual Guidance we maintain boundaries that allow for a degree of privacy. We respect people’s minds and don’t intentionally go browsing in there without being invited. Even in sessions, during which clients have agreed to allow me access to their issues, I usually ask before directly ‘going in’ to sense what is going on directly.
As much as we habitually respect the social order in matters of personal space, those of us who are tuned to notice such things often sense it when someone is about to call. I often hear direct statements aimed at me, such as “Will you hand me that salt?” so that the actual request comes in like an echo.
In Family Constellation work the group takes on and plays out the roles of one person’s family. The work establishes a field of energy that contains the mind field of that family. Participants adopt postures and position themselves in the room to intentionally express family relationships. The group explores the energy SUBTEXT of that particular family dynamic.
It is fascinating to begin to sense in your body and perhaps find yourself acting out the emotions and conflicts of the family member you represent–without any cognitive knowledge of them! This can be a bit creepy. As the person whose family is being enacted validates what you bring through it’s a relief. This type of experience gives a glimpse of the extent to which we are each and all–constantly–influenced by the other minds with which we interconnect.
How have YOU experienced interconnection from mind to mind?
What are your thoughts and feelings about the collective nature of the mind itself?













